Pennyworth vs. Gotham: A Gritty Dive into the Batman Lore (Minus Batman, Mostly)
So, you’re immersed in the Bat-verse. You’ve explored the streets of Gotham. You’ve seen young Bruce Wayne’s struggles. Now, you might wonder if Pennyworth, the tale of the butler, is worth your binge time. Get ready, Bat-fans. We’re diving into these two shows to see if Alfred’s story matches the chaos of Gotham.
Series Connections and Canon: Are They Playing in the Same Gotham Sandbox?
First, let’s tackle the key question scratching your Bat-brain: Is Pennyworth in Gotham’s universe? It is valid. The timelines and multiverses of DC Comics can confuse. You wouldn’t want Alfred serving tea to another Bruce from a different realm. Total chaos ensues!
Is Pennyworth in the Same Universe as Gotham?
Let’s be clear: yes, Pennyworth is in the same universe as Gotham. It’s a prequel detailing events before the bat-dominated Wayne Manor. Bruno Heller, the creator of both shows, confirmed, “yes, yes it does.” Pennyworth fits into Gotham’s timeline. That’s straight from the Bat-creator.
How is Pennyworth Connected to Gotham?
Alright, they share a universe. How are they linked? Well, Pennyworth tells Alfred’s origin story, years before Gotham begins. We’re in 1960s London, far from Gotham City’s dark alleys. The show highlights young Alfred long before he knows Bruce Wayne. It introduces a young Thomas Wayne. This lays the groundwork for the Wayne family legacy.
Think of it this way: Gotham depicts the city’s decay and Bruce’s struggles. Pennyworth rewinds to show Alfred’s origins, his experiences before he found Gotham and his first encounters with the Waynes. It’s like the opening act before the big show, the appetizer before the Bat-burger.
Interestingly, there’s a crossover! Sid Onslow appears in Pennyworth and is mentioned in Gotham. It’s a small nod but it connects both shows—an Easter egg for keen viewers. It’s akin to spotting a hidden Bat-symbol in plain sight.
Is Pennyworth Canon to Gotham?
We noted this earlier, but let’s emphasize: Pennyworth is canon to Gotham. Bruno Heller’s confirmation is quite definitive. It’s not an alternate universe spin-off; it belongs to the same story thread. When watching Pennyworth, events happen in the same timeline as Gotham, just decades earlier. Backstory, pure and simple—with espionage and 60s flair.
Is Pennyworth a Prequel to Gotham?
Yes, absolutely. Pennyworth is a prequel to Gotham. It takes place earlier in the timeline. It dives into Alfred’s youth and his connection with Thomas Wayne before Bruce exists. Pennyworth even alters Gotham’s backstory: Bruce has an older sister, Samantha, who vanished before his birth. This detail was not mentioned in Gotham, adding intrigue to Wayne family lore.
Are Gotham and Pennyworth Connected?
To recap, Gotham and Pennyworth are directly connected. They share creators, settings, and Alfred’s younger self is played by Jack Bannon. He represents the character originally portrayed by Sean Pertwee in Gotham. It broadens the Batman mythos, exploring key characters’ earlier lives before the caped crusader emerged.
Is Pennyworth a Spin-off of Gotham?
While Pennyworth is a prequel and exists in the same universe, calling it a “spin-off” may be misleading. It serves as a companion piece, expanding Gotham’s world through a specific character. Spin-offs often continue storylines directly from the original series. Pennyworth tells its own distinct narrative set in 1960s London, showcasing Alfred’s youthful days and early ties with the Wayne family.
Watching Order: Gotham First or Pennyworth First? The Eternal Binge-Watching Dilemma
A long-standing query with prequels: should you watch Gotham or Pennyworth first? There isn’t a single “correct” choice, so let’s break down the pros and cons to guide your viewing journey. Think of it as choosing between a Bat-gadget or a cup of Alfred’s tea—they both have their charms, depending on your mood.
Should I Watch Gotham or Pennyworth First?
If you prefer order, then Pennyworth should come first. Being Alfred’s origin story, it sets the stage for his connections to the Waynes. Watching it first provides insights into Alfred’s background and his relationship with Thomas Wayne. However, Gotham was released first and introduces Batman’s world in an accessible manner.
Gotham gives you a broader understanding of Batman lore first; then Pennyworth dives into one character’s history. It’s akin to exploring the city before focusing on a specific neighborhood—you grasp the entire territory first.
Ultimately, you decide. If you want a chronological experience, start with Pennyworth. If you prefer familiar territory first, watch Gotham before Pennyworth. Both paths deliver unique viewing experiences.
Should I Watch Pennyworth Before Gotham?
As we mentioned, watching Pennyworth before Gotham is valid., especially for those curious about Alfred’s journey and his early ties with the Waynes. Pennyworth deepens your understanding of Alfred’s character and military past, explaining how he became Batman’s loyal butler. It’s like getting Alfred’s recipe for Bat-cookies before you discover Batman.
The series is labeled a “no-brainer,” starting chronologically as it tackles Alfred’s origins and meeting Thomas and Martha Wayne before Bruce arrives. Even without Batman at first (initially), it’s vital backstory. So, if you want Alfred’s journey detailed first, then start with Pennyworth.
What Series Should I Watch After Gotham?
You’ve conquered Gotham—or perhaps even Pennyworth—and still desire more Bat-content. What lies next on the binge-list? The DC universe is expansive and diverse, offering many options. Here are series you might want to explore post-Gotham:
- Gotham Knights (2023): Focusing on Batman’s adopted son and children of his foes.
- Batwoman (2019-2022): Starring Kate Kane as Batwoman within the Arrowverse.
- Titans (2018-2023): A darker version of Teen Titans.
- Superman & Lois (2021-2024): Centered on Superman and Lois as parents in Smallville.
- Arrow (2012-2020): The show that initiated the Arrowverse, showcasing Green Arrow.
And don’t forget Pennyworth: The Origin of Batman’s Butler (2019-2022), if you haven’t seen it yet. Each series highlights different aspects of the DC universe—from street-level heroes to cosmic champions.
There is always something to scratch your superhero itch after Gotham.
Character Relationships: Alfred, Batman, and the Wayne Family
The dynamics between Alfred and the Waynes hold a special place in Pennyworth and Gotham. Batman needs a support system, and Alfred is essential to the Bat-family. Is he Batman’s dad in any way other than as a father-figure?
Is Pennyworth Batman’s Dad?
No. Alfred Pennyworth is not Batman’s biological father. Let’s set that straight before wild fan theories start. Thomas Wayne is Bruce Wayne’s dad. Nevertheless, Alfred is a father figure to Bruce after the tragic loss of Thomas and Martha Wayne. He steps in to raise Bruce, guide him, and provide needed emotional support. Alfred is more than a butler; he acts as a confidant, mentor, and second father.
Alfred’s role is more than just parenting. He serves as Batman’s conscience, grounding him when crime fighting becomes overwhelming. He holds the Bat-Family together, offering compassion and guidance. Although not related by blood, Alfred’s influence on Bruce is key to the Batman mythos. He’s the dad Batman needs, even if he’s not the one he was born with.
How is Pennyworth Connected to Batman?
We know Alfred connects to Batman through Pennyworth, but there’s more to explore. Alfred Thaddeus Crane Pennyworth is Bruce Wayne’s loyal valet at Wayne Manor. He is among the few who know Bruce is Batman and supports him in fighting crime. Alfred’s abilities make him invaluable to Batman’s efforts.
Pennyworth shows Alfred’s growth before serving Bruce. It depicts his past as an SAS soldier, his security firm, and his job with Thomas Wayne. This backstory deepens our understanding of Alfred and highlights his fierce loyalty and capability when working for Bruce. It’s like viewing the blueprint for the ultimate ally in the Batman saga.
Who is Bruce Wayne’s Sister?
Pennyworth introduces a curveball in Batman lore. Bruce Wayne has an older sister named Samantha in the prequel series Pennyworth. This differs from the comics where Bruce is typically shown as an only child. Samantha went missing well before Bruce’s birth, adding mystery and secrets to the Wayne family. It’s like unearthing a hidden chapter in their history.
This revelation raises questions about Samantha’s fate and the effects her disappearance had on Thomas and Martha Wayne, eventually impacting Bruce. Pennyworth introduces this new element to enhance the Wayne family’s dynamics while opening up storylines. It’s a family secret that could have consequences throughout the Batman universe.
Who is Bruce Wayne’s Uncle?
In early Batman stories, Bruce Wayne had an uncle named Philip Wayne who became his legal guardian after his parents died. Philip is not as prominent now, with Alfred filling the guardian role. Philip Wayne is almost a relic from the Silver Age, fading as Batman’s story evolved. He’s like a distant relative in the larger Wayne family tree.
Pennyworth doesn’t explore Philip Wayne; it focuses on Alfred’s ties to Thomas and Martha and introduces Samantha Wayne. The series appears to craft its own version of Wayne family history, possibly sidelining less relevant characters from earlier comics.
Did Thomas and Martha Wayne Have a Daughter?
Yes, according to Pennyworth, Thomas and Martha Wayne had a daughter named Samantha. Samantha is Bruce’s elder sister who vanished before he was born. This adds a significant dimension to the Wayne family, introducing a hidden sister aspect that wasn’t part of Batman lore. Samantha is now a family secret, an unknown child of Martha and Thomas.
The revelation of Samantha adds to the Wayne family tragedy. Bruce lost his parents and never knew he had a sister. This could affect Bruce’s character development and motivations as Batman, deepening a sense of loss and history in his complex psyche. It’s like finding a missing puzzle piece, revealing another layer to the Wayne family’s story.
How Old Was Bruce Wayne When He Left Gotham?
In various Batman arcs, Bruce Wayne leaves Gotham around age 14 to begin a global journey of self-improvement and skill acquisition. He travels, seeking experts in martial arts and other disciplines vital to his future as Batman. This training period is crucial for his development into the Dark Knight.
Scenes of Bruce training as a teenager appear in comics and adaptations, including college experiences and his time with the FBI at age 20. This part of his journey shapes him into the capable crime fighter he becomes. It’s like Batman’s training montage, crucial to his transformation from orphaned child to Caped Crusader.
Why is Alfred So Loyal to Batman?
Alfred’s loyalty comes from his bond with Bruce Wayne, formed through tragedy and years of support. Alfred has been a father figure since Bruce was only 8, following his parents’ murder. He raised Bruce, providing guidance, stability, and care through grief.
When Bruce chose to be Batman, Alfred stood by him, giving help, tactical advice, and emotional backing. Alfred’s medical knowledge makes him Batman’s go-to surgeon, tending to Bruce’s wounds. His loyalty springs from love, duty, and commitment to Bruce’s mission and well-being. It’s loyalty forged in fire, like the Bat-signal shining in Gotham’s night.
How Much Older is Alfred Than Bruce?
The age gap varies across Batman versions, but typically, it’s about 22 years. Alfred is roughly 22 years older than Bruce. This difference highlights Alfred’s father-figure role, explaining his wisdom and experience that he shares with Bruce. It’s a generational divide contributing to their dynamic, with Alfred as the mentor and Bruce as the ambitious protégé. It’s like a wise owl guiding a fledgling bat.
Pennyworth as a Series: Is it Worth Your Time?
Let’s answer the main question: is Pennyworth worth your time? With so many superhero shows out there, does Pennyworth truly stand out, or is it just another blip? Let’s analyze the pros and cons of watching Alfred’s solo adventures.
Is Pennyworth Worth Watching?
The general view is that Pennyworth is indeed worth watching, especially for Batman enthusiasts or fans of spy thrillers with a retro feel. Critics and audiences praise Pennyworth for its sleek ‘60s vibe, grittiness, and Jack Bannon’s portrayal of a young, complex Alfred. It breaks the mold of a typical superhero show; it feels more like a spy thriller connected to Batman.
Pennyworth is described as an “amalgam of classic ’60s spy series paired with modern cinematic sensibilities.” It’s engaging, unique, and provides a different lens into the Batman universe by exploring Alfred’s backstory. If you’re seeking something fresh in the superhero genre, Pennyworth might be your ideal choice.
Why Did Pennyworth Get Cancelled?
Sadly, Pennyworth was cancelled by HBO Max after three seasons. The cancellation came amidst broader changes at DC Studios under James Gunn and Peter Safran, who announced
a reboot of the DC franchise led to Pennyworth’s cancellation. Alongside Doom Patrol and Titans, it fell victim to corporate changes. Many shows suffer under these circumstances. Good programs sometimes become collateral damage in business decisions.
Will There Be a Season 4 for Pennyworth?
Unfortunately, there will be no season 4 for Pennyworth. HBO Max confirmed its cancellation. Fans should not expect any revival. It’s disappointing when a beloved show ends prematurely, but that’s TV for you. Stories sometimes wrap up, even when we’d like more.
What Era is Pennyworth Set In?
Pennyworth takes place in 1960s London. It’s a gritty setting set decades before Gotham’s timeline. The show embraces a vivid ’60s style, encompassing fashion, music, and the spy thriller vibe. This choice gives Pennyworth a unique identity, different from Gotham’s modern backdrop. It feels like visiting a groovy sixties Batman universe.
Is Pennyworth an Alternate Universe?
Pennyworth aims to connect to Gotham, but it strays from established Batman lore. It creates an alternate universe in some ways. Described as being in “an alternate universe,” it surprises viewers with deviations from tradition. Expect unexpected plot twists and creative freedom. It’s a remix of Batman themes in a fresh way.
Is Pennyworth Part of the DC Universe?
Yes, Pennyworth fits into the broader DC Universe, in a television context. The show is based on the Batman property from DC Comics. While some details may differ from the “main universe,” it stays linked to the DC universe and Gotham’s storyline. It’s a branch of the DC tree, with its unique growth pattern.
Is Pennyworth Part of the Arrowverse?
No, Pennyworth does not belong to the Arrowverse. This is a different DC television universe with shows like Arrow and The Flash. Pennyworth has its own continuity, separate from Arrowverse and other DC series. It connects to Gotham but remains distinct from the wider Arrowverse. Imagine an island in the DC TV archipelago.
Who Does Pennyworth End Up With?
In Pennyworth, Alfred’s love interest is Esme Winikus. Their relationship is a central emotional thread throughout the series. Alfred eventually proposes to Esme, hinting at a deep bond. But tragedy strikes (typical for Batman’s world), bringing unexpected darkness to their love story. It’s complicated and bittersweet.
How Old is Alfred in Pennyworth?
Alfred is portrayed as a 26-year-old in Pennyworth. This Alfred differs from the one we associate with Batman’s older, wise persona. He’s a former SAS soldier wrestling with his past and seeking purpose. The series dives into Alfred’s journey as a complex man finding his place. It’s a look at his formative years before Wayne Manor.
Pennyworth’s Character Depiction: More Than Just a Butler, Apparently
Alfred Pennyworth is often thought of as a classic butler, always lurking. But Pennyworth, the series, intends to explore his character more deeply, showcasing hidden layers and surprises. Is he secretly the Joker in disguise? Let’s examine some wild theories and his character portrayal.
Is Pennyworth the Joker?
Let’s address this fan theory: is Pennyworth actually the Joker? The answer is no. There’s a comic where Alfred becomes the Joker in an alternate universe. But in the show and main canon, he’s distinct from the Joker. Alfred has different motivations and personality traits. The idea serves more as a thought experiment.
In Pennyworth, Alfred has a grounded persona with military roots and strong morals. He’s not near the chaotic Joker’s character. You can rest assured, he won’t unveil a painted grin or laugh maniacally. Alfred stands firmly with the Bat-family.
Can Alfred Pennyworth Beat Superman?
Let’s discuss Alfred’s fighting skills. Can Alfred Pennyworth defeat Superman? It seems absurd at first. Superman possesses immense power. But in the Injustice universe, an incredible event occurs. Alfred, with special tech, manages to take down Superman. With Batman’s distraction, he gets a power boost and defeats Superman. It’s shocking but showcases Alfred’s unique abilities.
This rare victory showcases Alfred’s willingness to protect Batman at all costs. It highlights that he is not just a butler but also a formidable figure in dire situations. He proves himself capable when pressed to the edge.
Who is the Strongest Version of Alfred Pennyworth?
When discussing power levels, DCeased’s Alfred Pennyworth could be the mightiest. In this story, Alfred gains the Spectre’s powers, giving him incredible strength. He can defeat New Gods effortlessly. This version of Alfred is vastly powerful, far removed from the traditional butler role. He embodies raw potential and strength.
This portrayal is an alternate reality and does not represent his standard image. But it shows how even ordinary characters can attain extraordinary powers in comic book worlds.
Who Has Beaten Superman Without Kryptonite?
Many characters have defeated Superman sans Kryptonite. Some relied on cunning and strategy. They target Superman’s other vulnerabilities, like magic or psychological manipulation. Examples include Maxwell Lord and Lex Luthor. Even Alfred Pennyworth has found success in some scenarios. Batman has also devised plans without Kryptonite.
These instances confirm Superman isn’t invincible. Clever foes can find ways to outsmart him without his well-known weakness. It’s a tribute to human intelligence against superhuman strength.
Who is Smarter Batman or Alfred?
Batman earns praise for his intellect, with an IQ of 192. He’s a brilliant inventor and strategist. However, Alfred is no slouch either. With an estimated IQ around 150, he brings wisdom, experience, and practical smarts. He aids Batman with strategy and crucial advice.
and even guides him through missions via comms.
Batman may have a higher IQ, but Alfred’s experience makes him a crucial partner. Their intellects work together to form a strong team. Batman plans strategically. Alfred provides wisdom. Together, they create synergy like a brain and heart united in purpose.
Who is Alfred’s Favorite Robin?
The question that many Bat-fans ask is who is Alfred’s favorite Robin? The answer is simple: Alfred loves them all. He sees their distinct qualities and offers support. He acts like a kind grandfather to every Robin who has worn the mantle.
Yet, some stories hint at a special Robin. Alfred left his fortune to Richard (Dick Grayson, the first Robin). This shows his trust in Richard’s capabilities and intention to do good. It does not mean he loves the other Robins less. It shows he views Richard as capable of carrying on a legacy while loving each equally. Like a wise parent with children, he acknowledges their unique strengths.
Gotham as a Series: More Than Just a Batman Prequel?
Let’s talk about Gotham. This series started it all before Pennyworth came along. What is Gotham the equivalent of in real life? And what led to its end?
What is Gotham the Equivalent Of?
Gotham City visually resembles an exaggerated New York City. But its unique identity also draws from other cities. Chicago’s architecture, Tokyo’s elevated roads, and the “walled city of Kalhoon” from Hong Kong all shaped Gotham’s look.
Gotham is designed to show a hyper-urban crime-ridden city. It reflects the dark tone of Batman’s world. The city hangs on the edge of chaos, serving as a playground for heroes and villains alike. It embodies urban anxieties, creating a fictional space of tensions, blending elements from New York, Chicago, Tokyo, and Hong Kong.
Why Did They Cancel Gotham?
Gotham had a good run. Fox renewed it for a fifth season to finish DC Comics super-villains’ origin story. The end was not due to low ratings. It was always meant to conclude the narrative arc. The creators believed five seasons were enough to explore Gotham’s rogues and Bruce Wayne before he became Batman.
Fans might have wanted more Gotham, but the showrunners planned a proper ending. They wished to wrap up storylines while offering closure. It’s like when you read a book and reach its last chapter, knowing it’s where the journey was meant to lead, despite feeling bittersweet about its conclusion.
Will Gotham Ever Return?
Although Gotham wrapped up after its fifth season, revivals or spin-offs are always a possibility. Currently, there are no plans for the show to return in its original format. Its story has concluded, and attention shifts to other Batman-related media like Gotham Knights.
The world of TV and fan interests constantly evolves. A revival is always possible. In superhero media, never say never. For now, Gotham’s tale has been told, signaling a time to venture into other Batman universe tales.
What to Watch if You Like Gotham?
If you liked Gotham’s dark tone and villain origins, here are some series to check out:
- Gotham Knights (2023): Set after Batman’s death, featuring his adopted son and enemies’ children.
- Batwoman (2019-2022): Focuses on Kate Kane as Batwoman in the Arrowverse.
- Titans (2018-2023): A mature angle on the Teen Titans, showcasing darker superhero themes.
- Superman & Lois (2021-2024): A more hopeful take but contains complex character drama.
- Arrow (2012-2020): The series that started the Arrowverse with urban crime themes.
- Pennyworth: The Origin of Batman’s Butler (2019-2022): Explore Alfred’s backstory for more Gotham-adjacent content.
